Rejecting of comments
Telling someone that their comment was meanspirited, should have not resulted with a rejection to post. There are some insulting and demeaning comments that definitely should have been rejected, but weren't. But, Hey Yahoo, it's your platform! I'm out!
jan flig
shared this idea
Hello. While we cannot speak about specific comments, policy interpretations, or actions action in relation to specific comments outside of with their original poster, we seek to apply the Yahoo Community Guidelines as evenly, fairly, and objectively as possible.
-
james vierling
commented
When a comment fails to publish for no reason provide a way to get the comment approved. When suddenly someone can not publish any comments at least tell them why. I get very sick of every time I turn around my comments fail to publish when I violated no rules at all. It is getting to the point of really hating your site. Why is it every month I get a notice from Experian that my yahoo email address was found on the dark web with the password when I change it every time I get the notice?
-
Bill Ferro
commented
23 minutes ago
Those cases were not thrown out because there was no merit. Those cases were not heard at all by corrupt courts. There is a difference. Not heard is not the same as thrown out.
Your comment failed to publish.
RetryJust Now
Replying to ShindiMany of the cases went in front of judges appointed by tRump. Does it really make sense to you that all 60+ cases throughout different parts of the country were all against tRump.
I'd like to know why my comment was rejected.
-
Fred Peterson
commented
Approve my comments.
-
Derrick Stevenson
commented
Allow people to post facts. I commented that Cohen was convicted of perjury, my comment was rejected.
-
Leonard Ray
commented
Start allowing rejections to be appealed again. I had a post rejected for saying some did not understand the subject and needed to learn about the subject. No insults or vulgarity were inthe post.
-
Eduardo Shanon
commented
Stop with the not allowing me to post. You Americans are so big on First Amendment, yet I'm censored? What Gives? There are comments on here that are racist, homophobic, and worse, yet I'm reined in for being honest?
-
Jonny D
commented
1. Flag/Highlight what in the comment is causing the issue. When we type out a comment that reaches the character limit and then it gets rejected, we have no idea what actually caused it to get rejected. This includes times when you get a warning before posting that what we wrote could cause it to get rejected.
2. Bring back the ability to appeal comment rejections
3. Show the comment that was rejected in the notification emails. It used to do this, but now it just says the title of the article that the comment was rejected on.
-
Judy Wafle
commented
evidently I am banned from responding to news. Never told why since I do not swear or suggested any violent response. If I could eliminate yahoo I would but have been a user for decades and have the email.
-
george t
commented
explain why you reject posts that are 100% copy and pasted from the article ?
if someone misses something in an article, and someone posts the relevant section, are you afraid they may take it as an insult or what ? -
Scott Davis
commented
When you arbitrarily reject a comment after the fact, you used to tell us which comment it was. by not doing that you are silencing speech. Why did you stop showing the comment? Most of the time we are getting rejected for a single word and we have no idea why. Either update your algorithm to highlight the offending word so we can edit it on the spot, or show us the comment so we can reapply it with an edit. and considering the hatred i see from left leaning comments especially in your thread, you are not censoring everyone.
-
Gray Kellom
commented
On every news article I try to comment on, I get a "Your comment failed to publish" no matter how many times I try to resubmit or hit "Retry." What's going on?
-
Lefty Slapper
commented
If you morons are gonna say my comments violate your bulls*** policy then cite the part of the policy that I am violating. Don't just send me an email that says my appeal was rejected. Liberal pukes!
-
marty shamburg
commented
I have been commenting to news articles for years, without problems, but not able to for about a week or so. I have tried in several articles this past week without success.
-
marty shamburg
commented
I have not been able to post in the comments to news articles for about a week, and don't know why my comments will not publish.
-
Chris Rasmussen
commented
YAHOO: Fix your algorithm or hire human beings to police comments. Your rejections have run amuck.
Today's news featured the heartwarming story, "Cat-astrophe diverted: Family reunited with cat after they accidentally ship it out with return."
My response was somehow rejected: "This is the kind of story that takes the dread out of opening my laptop to take in the news. Big Thanks to author Becca Wood for a purrrfect start to my day!"
I'm speechless!
-
Brian Reed
commented
Everyone has an opinion, and they don't always align. But to silence so many peoples post or comments due to the fact that they don't align with your extreme leftists views! My comment singled no one out, was respectful to all and violated no rules or laws. But since you want to portray only the extreme lefts views, you silence those who RESPECTFULLY give another view. You are and absolutel garbage news agency and you need sued down to your underwear for the trash you post under the guise of "news"!!
-
Nicholas Dodson
commented
Our nation is sliding rapidly into an abyss of no return.
We cannot discuss issues if the level of discourse is set to that a of a 4th grade level.
Sometimes when we discuss news items that have us on the brink of war, total social collapse, or economic ruin, we use words that have more than one meaning. Your censorship program is unable to discern context of the conversation, and every day words are taken in the wrong context and either the post is deleted or blocked.
Yahoo, I think you also know that there are people within other countries that want serious harm to befall our nation and they post on your website. Yet you seem to worry more for them than you do for the people who live in the nation where you originate.
Currently the comment boards are not useful for anything but venting as it is impossible to have rational discussions here because of the algorithms you employ.
-
Brazos 78
commented
Seems as though we've been randomly selected to be censored because our ideas do not meet Yahoo's left-wing program. Thus the comments are skewed. Too bad Yahoo. Try as you may, most of our country doesn't think like you want us to.....and we won't.
-
Linda Fish
commented
Some times people respond to my comments with vile language and sexual content, like a guy suggesting that as a woman I just need to "get down on all fours". Why do I get restriction notices if I mention a body part or capitalize a word and there are folks who send me vile and inappropriate responses that are not rejected.
-
Michael Hotaling
commented
Fix this mess. It's almost impossible to hold a conversation with anybody. I came here, because it wasn't being run like MSN. MSN is now a graveyard for conversation. Is this what Yahoo wants?
Be well