Hi, please share your suggestions, we are listening

Remove political and other irrelevant discussions from the finance message boards

Political posts overtake the message boards, rendering what used to be a great tool close to unusable. Looking at the first screen of GE message boards, I can't find anything but the arguing about global warming.

To solve - allow to vote down users AND posts, and if a user or post gets enough down votes from high ranking users (or by some other similar determination), hide all the posts from the user and do not allow to post for that user for one day.

255 votes
Vote
Sign in
Check!
(thinking…)
Reset
or sign in with
  • facebook
  • google
    Password icon
    Signed in as (Sign out)
    You have left! (?) (thinking…)
    sergdsergd shared this idea  ·   ·  Flag idea as inappropriate…  ·  Admin →
    JimmyJimmy shared a merged idea: Message boards FULL of spam all the time - what is Yahoo! going to do?!?!  ·   · 
    alphonitealphonite shared a merged idea: Spam and Scams are destroying the integrity of all boards  ·   · 
    bob breaubob breau shared a merged idea: foul disgusting language by a few on WWE ruin experience for many!  ·   · 
    alphonitealphonite shared a merged idea: . SCAM BAIT multiplyed by thousands through the sea of Yahoo Finance Message Boards. . Altho the illeterate infintile names and messages ha  ·   · 
    Freddy WatersFreddy Waters shared a merged idea: The MNST board has been utterly taken over and destroyed by continuous commercial spam. Please help get rid of it!  ·   · 
    Ed BuckEd Buck shared a merged idea: Block racist words for whites used in the comment section. Yahoo blocks racist words for every race except whites.  ·   · 
    JMJM shared a merged idea: Yahoo needs to do a much better job of moderating the WWE message board in Yahoo Finance.  ·   · 
    DTDT shared a merged idea: Turn off Finance message boards (or post as "For Entertainment Only" ... I'm fed up with the spam, virus-laiden link refs & drivel  ·   · 
    Anonymous shared a merged idea: Stop the spam.  ·   · 
    composerx1composerx1 shared a merged idea: cisco board is nothing but useless political junk  ·   · 
    DougDoug shared a merged idea: Please find a way to get rid of all the junk post in the finance forums!!  ·   · 
    SteveSteve shared a merged idea: your message boards are being ruined by the spamers.  ·   · 
    composerx1composerx1 shared a merged idea: what does this or most posts on cisco message board have to do with stocks ? ABSOLUTELY NOTHING !!  ·   · 
    composerx1composerx1 shared a merged idea: perfect example of message board junk  ·   · 
    LeeLee shared a merged idea: Message boards have less political drivel. Thank you, but your work is not finished.  ·   · 
    composerx1composerx1 shared a merged idea: does this look like its about stocks ?  ·   · 
    Joel StronbergJoel Stronberg shared a merged idea: Exhibit some social responsibility on your finance message boards; lead by example.  ·   · 
    AlbertoAlberto shared a merged idea: Your comment section is repulsive. It troubles me that I have to look at racist comments on every topic/subject.  ·   · 
    Anonymous shared a merged idea: Yahoo down the toilet  ·   · 
    Anonymous shared a merged idea: Why has Yahoo not clearned up the abusive horrible posts at Ceragon, CRNT? Are you going to fix it???  ·   · 
    George HadjiGeorge Hadji shared a merged idea: How does this poster manage to  ·   · 
    Anonymous shared a merged idea: get rid of poster "mcksym" on NEOSTEM board  ·   · 

    15 comments

    Sign in
    Check!
    (thinking…)
    Reset
    or sign in with
    • facebook
    • google
      Password icon
      Signed in as (Sign out)
      Submitting...
      • HowardHoward commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

        Yahoo Finance either needs a monitor to read all messages before posting or just do away with the message board.They are filled with messages that are mean, biased, have nothing to do with the stock in point, are spam, ads, etc.

      • Joe BlowJoe Blow commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

        This is easy to fix.
        5 of the same posts from the same ID on 5 different boards within 15 seconds disables the ID and removes all the posts from that ID.
        Robo spam posts the same post on dozens of boards per minute - a human poster cannot duplicate this. This would also allow active links to be turned back on which is a valuable tool for legitimate posters (and kind of the point of the internet!)
        YAHOO - YOU CAN STOP THIS IF YOU CHOOSE TO without encumbering legitimate posters.
        SPAM has forced me off the USO board. Nearly every post of the dozens in the last day or two has been robo spam. I'm done with it.
        YAHOO - YOU CAN STOP THIS IF YOU CHOOSE TO!!!!

      • Anonymous commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

        This is easy to fix.
        5 of the same posts from the same ID on 5 different boards within 15 seconds disables the ID and removes all the posts from that ID.
        Robo spam posts the same post on dozens of boards per minute - a human poster cannot duplicate this.
        YAHOO - YOU CAN STOP THIS IF YOU CHOOSE TO without encumbering legitimate posters.
        SPAM has forced me off the USO board. Nearly every post of the dozens in the last day or two has been robo spam. I'm done with it.
        YAHOO - YOU CAN STOP THIS IF YOU CHOOSE TO!!!!

      • Anonymous commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

        This is easy to fix.
        5 of the same posts from the same ID on 5 different boars within 15 seconds disables the ID and removes all the posts from that ID.
        Robo spam posts the same post on dozens of boards per minute - a human poster cannot duplicate this.
        YAHOO - YOU CAN STOP THIS IF YOU CHOOSE TO without encumbering legitimate posters.
        SPAM has forced me off the USO board. Nearly ever post of the dozens in the last day or two has been robo spam. I'm done with it.
        YAHOO - YOU CAN STOP THIS IF YOU CHOOSE TO!!!!

      • Anonymous commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

        Why does Yahoo have the "Flag" option to "Report Abuse" if they NEVER seems to remove flagged spam, profanity, serial posts, topics and comments that are not about a company or industry, arguments between posters, etc?

        It seems that Yahoo claims to be making an effort to improve their sites and services in order to turn their share price around, but the sites are getting worse, and the services have been cut !

      • Anonymous commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

        if it becomes possible for anonymous users to vote other users off the boards, then one person with many fake logins will eliminate everyone they choose. it will become a deletion war.

        just ignore people you don't want to see. and learn to ignore things you don't want to read, if you can't assert leadership to prevent them from happening in your neighborhood.

      • BryanBryan commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

        BRK-A is the worst. Script user is creating scores of new accounts each day and flooding the message board with repeated messages. This has been reported, however Yahoo says the Finance Boards are not monitored and no action will be taken.

      • composerx1composerx1 commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

        INSTEAD OF MERGING COMPLAINTS WHY DONT YOU TAKE CARE OF THE PROBLEM INSTEAD .. SUCH IDIOTS . IS THIS YOUR IDEA OF MAKING THE BOARD BETTER ??? MERGING THE COMPLAINTS INSTEAD OF FIXING WHATS WRONG ?

      • composerx1composerx1 commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

        Get this junk OFF THE MESSAGE BOARDS !!

        LYING Democrats at it again
        by fluteman_greg Jan 6, 2013 5:54 PM

      • composerx1composerx1 commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

        Now this is appropriate for a stock message board : TOTALLY USELESS BOARD. YAHOO COULD CARE LESS

        O'Bama loves to eat dogs, one of his favorite dogs to eat is Shih Tzu
        by ivanhoeofoloxly Jan 6, 2013 5:24 PM

      • mattmatt commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

        Why would Yahoo ever do what they are supposed too? They over pay their new CEO who has done nothing but make Yahoo worse, The board has no clue whats going on but enjoys reaping the benefits and pay, and this entire feedback section looks like its all for show but not for solving any issues.

      • JoeJoe commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

        Please Yahoo, common, why is it so hard to look at a Board and clean it up and kick off troll posters that infest all the time?

        Many Yahoo good people are disgusted by the lack of effective and quick censoring of such trash and abuse.

        We need faster help on this problem!!!

      • JoeJoe commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

        As of today, the Ceragon CRNT Yahoo Finance Board is still out of control with grossly vulgar and obnoxious multiple trolls that are posting every day, constantly. They target one poster in particular, a poster by the name of Greedyone222. Greedyone222 claims he is a victim of some sick person who is in Europe and wants to drive him crazy. The posts have been on *** topics, private body parts, insulting by attacking a person's mother, and smearing a person in all kinds of revoluting ways.
        It is a mystery how and why Yahoo Censors are not responding to kick off the troll posters since Yahoo claims they can trace to the ISP number and block access.
        This abuse has been ongoing for a long time, months, and even last year.
        However, lately, some posts have been removed by the Censors, but they leave others intact that are equally as bad. It makes no sense. It is hoped that Yahoo will finally figure out a solution and take action to stop this contant troll abuse.

      Feedback and Knowledge Base